Back to Blog
    Koi & Fish CareBy Shawn Cutroni· Published November 9, 2023· 6 min read

    Winter Koi Care in New England: How Koi Survive Under the Ice

    Koi pond in winter with a partly frozen surface

    Koi are not just summer fish. A healthy koi in a properly built New England pond can spend four or five months under ice and come out in spring ready to feed and grow. What decides whether that happens is not luck or a heater. It is depth, open water for gas exchange, feeding discipline, and a pond that went into winter clean.

    Here is how we overwinter koi for clients across Massachusetts, Rhode Island, Connecticut and New Hampshire, and what we tell owners to watch for between December and March.

    What koi do in winter

    Koi are cold-blooded, so their body temperature follows the water. As the pond cools through fall, their metabolism slows. By the time ice forms they settle near the deepest part of the pond, barely move, and live off the reserves they built up over summer. This is a resting state, not a problem to fix. The job of the pond owner is to protect that resting state, not to wake it up.

    Depth: why 2 feet is enough

    We build ponds to a 2 foot standard depth. In a New England winter the surface ices over, but even in a hard cold snap the ice only reaches several inches thick, leaving a stable layer of liquid water below where the fish rest. Shallower ponds are the ones at risk of freezing too deep. If you want the full reasoning, see our article on the ideal depth for your pond.

    For larger koi collections we can design a deeper fish zone, but for most backyard ponds the 2 foot depth, good circulation and filtration sized to the fish load matter far more than extra depth.

    Keep one hole open in the ice

    Ice on its own does not hurt koi. A sealed ice cap does. Fish and decomposing organic matter release carbon dioxide and other gases, and when the surface is frozen solid those gases have nowhere to go. Over weeks they build up under the ice and stress the fish.

    The fix is a single opening, kept open all winter:

    • Floating de-icer. A thermostat-controlled de-icer keeps a small hole open and only runs when it needs to. Typical units are 100 to 300 watts, and because they cycle on and off, a winter of de-icer use usually adds only a small amount to a monthly electric bill. We break down the numbers in how much electricity a pond actually uses.
    • Small aerator. A low-wattage air pump with the air stone set near the surface, not on the bottom, keeps gentle movement and an opening without mixing the colder surface water down to where the fish are resting.

    You need an opening, not a warm pond. Trying to heat the whole pond wastes electricity and is not necessary for koi or goldfish to overwinter.

    Never smash the ice

    If the pond does freeze over completely, do not hit the ice with a shovel or mallet. Water transmits the shock straight through to the fish, and a blow that seems harmless from above can injure or kill dormant koi. Set a pot of hot water on the ice to melt an opening, or drill through it gently, then get a de-icer or aerator running. More on that in why you should not break up the ice.

    Feeding: stop at 55°F

    This is the rule we hold firmly in New England. Stop feeding in fall once the water drops below 55°F, and do not start again until the water holds a consistent 55°F in spring. Many general guides use 50°F. We wait for 55°F because New England falls and springs swing hard between warm afternoons and cold nights, and food eaten during a warm spell can sit undigested in a fish whose metabolism has already slowed.

    Uneaten food is a second problem. It sinks, rots and adds to the waste breaking down under the ice. A thermometer in the water, not the air temperature, is what decides feeding. When in doubt, do not feed. Healthy koi will not starve over a New England winter.

    Go into winter with a clean pond

    Leaves are the biggest winter risk most owners do not see. Oak and maple leaves that sink in fall rot all winter, using oxygen and producing the gases you are trying to vent. That is why we net ponds before the leaves drop, usually in October, and remove the net before heavy snow.

    Cold water beneficial bacteria help break down organic matter at temperatures where standard pond bacteria stop working. We cover when and how to use it in cold water beneficial bacteria for winter pond prep.

    Pumps, waterfalls and winter

    Most ecosystem ponds in New England are shut down from late November to early April: the pump is pulled, stored indoors, and the plumbing is cleared so it cannot freeze and crack. Some owners keep the waterfall running all winter for the ice formations, and that can work with care. The risk is ice dams diverting water over the edge of the liner and draining the pond, so the water level has to be checked after every cold snap. If you travel or cannot check it, a proper shutdown is the safer choice.

    Signs something is wrong

    • Fish gasping or hanging right at the open hole in the ice, rather than resting near the bottom.
    • The opening has closed and you do not know for how long.
    • The water level has dropped noticeably, often from an ice dam on a running waterfall.
    • A strong rotten smell when the ice opens, which points to heavy organic buildup.

    Restore the opening first, without striking the ice. If fish are clearly stressed or the level keeps dropping, call us at (774) 437-1160 and we will talk you through it.

    Late winter: plan the spring wake-up now

    When the ice comes off, koi are at their weakest point of the year, and the pond is carrying a winter's worth of debris. A spring cleanout resets the pond before the fish start feeding and before algae gets a head start. Most Massachusetts ponds are ready in April, which is when every pond owner calls at once, so the best time to get on the schedule is during the winter.

    See our month-by-month spring startup guide for what happens next, or book your spring cleanout now to lock in an early date.

    Shawn Cutroni

    About the author

    Shawn Cutroni

    Founder & Co-Owner, Master Certified Aquascape Contractor

    Shawn Cutroni founded New England Aquatic Landscaping in 2008 after a backyard pond he built for his mother as a Christmas gift turned green within weeks. He spent the years that followed learning the biology, filtration and stone work that let a water feature sustain itself, became a Master Certified Aquascape Contractor, and rebuilt that first pond. Today he leads NEAL's construction, maintenance and office teams from Cherry Valley, Massachusetts, designing, building and servicing ecosystem ponds, koi ponds, pondless waterfalls and natural swimming ponds across New England. He also hosts the I Love Ponds YouTube channel, where he documents builds and answers pond owners' questions.

    More about Shawn and the NEAL team

    Our service

    Koi Ponds

    Purpose-built for koi health and viewing. Deeper water, superior filtration, and design elements that showcase your fish collection.

    See how we build them

    Have questions about your pond?

    Call Shawn or schedule a consultation.